91

2023 Clos de Luz Agras País, Cachapoal Valley

( £13.95, 12.5%, The Wine Society )

Agras uses a field blend of grapes from 100-year-old vines in the Cachapoal Valley, combining País and 10% Moscatel de Alejandría. Fermented with 20% whole bunches, it’s refreshingly low in alcohol at 12.5%, with jasmine and rose petal aromas, impressive underlying grip and concentration and a palate of redcurrant, cranberry and rooibos tea.

BuyDrinking window: 2026-30Similar Wines: £10-15, 990-94, Chile, Red, País, Moscatel de Alejandría
95

2024 Domaine Sérol Éclat de Granite, Côte Roannaise

( £15.50, 12%, The Wine Society )

It’s not from Beaujolais, the subject of my main piece this week, but it is made from Gamay (albeit the local Gamay Saint Romain clone). This is a stunning red from the little-known Loire Valley appellation of Côte Roannaise that saw me place an order within five minutes of tasting it at the Wine Society this week. Fermented and aged in concrete tanks with 20% whole bunches and not an oak barrel in sight, it’s tangy, refreshing and lightly grassy, with layers of plum, redcurrant and white pepper, granular tannins and a racy, lingering finish. One of the best-value reds I’ve had so far this year.

BuyDrinking window: 2026-32Similar Wines: £15-20, 95-100, France, Red, Gamay
94

2024 Villard Le Pinot Noir Grand Vin, Casablanca Valley

( £19, 13.5%, The Wine Society )

Given the price of red Burgundy these days, this Casablanca Valley Pinot Noir from Thierry and Charlie Villard  is a steal. Made with a 60/40 combination of the Valdivieso and 115 clones, it’s a graceful, scented, refined expression of the grape with succulent raspberry and goji berry flavours and a bright, energetic finish.

BuyDrinking window: 2026-31Similar Wines: £15-20, 90-94, Chile, Red, Pinot Noir
93

2021 Tenuta Terrose Vino Nobile de Montepulciano Riserva, Tuscany

( £16.95, 14%, The Co-op )

Based on the Sangiovese grape, known locally at Prugnolo Gentile, with support from 8% Cabernet Sauvignon and 7% Merlot,  this  is a very well-priced red from one of Tuscany’s most famous DOCGs. Showing the grip and focus that come with the territory, it has plum, damson and tobacco leaf flavours, sinewy tannins, a waft of black tea and Mediterranean herbs and nicely understated older oak.

BuyDrinking window: 2026-31Similar Wines: £15-20, 90-94, Italy, Red, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Prugnolo Gentile
96

2024 Sons of Sugarland Syrah, Polkadraai Hills, Stellenbosch

( £30, 14%, The Wine Society )

Almost ridiculously good at the price, this comes from an unoffocial Grand Cru Syrah parcel on the Karibib estate in the Polkadraai Hills and is as  good as a top northern Rhône red. Fermented with 100% whole bunches in concrete tanks, it has amazing depth and focus, aromas of clove and Negroni spices, layers of tapenade, oregano and blackberry, granite-derived freshness and a lingering, herbal finish.  Effortless brilliance from Reenen Borman.

BuyDrinking window: 2026-35Similar Wines: £30-35, 95-100, South Africa, Red, Syrah
93

2023 Te Kairanga John Martin Pinot Noir, Martinborough

( £21.25, 13%, Majestic )

Named after one of Martinborough’s pioneers, John Martin, this is a wonderfully bright, tangy, graceful Pinot Noir from one of New Zealand’s best North Island regions. Fresh, tangy and focused,  with nicely understated oak, it has a beguiling garnet hue, goji berry and wild strawberry fruit and a top note of crushed rose petal. Beautifully balanced.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-32Similar Wines: £20-25, 90-94, France, Red, Pinot Noir
94

2023 Zuccardi Polígonos Paraje Altamira Malbec, Uco Valley

( £26, 14%, Sainsbury's )

Part of a very strong range under Zuccardi’s Polígonos brand, this comes from cooler, south-facing vines at 1,100 metres in Paraje Altamira, one of the finest sun-regions of Argentina’s high-altitude Uco Valley. Markedly influenced by its limestone soils, it luxuriates in violet and wet stone aromas, lovely zip and acidity, chalky minerality and intense plum, damson and blackberry fruit flavours.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-35Similar Wines: £25-30, 90-94, Argentina, Red, Malbec
91

2023 Taste the Difference Côtes du Ventoux, Rhône Valley

( £11.50, 14.5%, Sainsbury's )

I always tend to drink more southern Rhône reds at this time of year. This one caught my eye at the recent Sainsbury’s press tasting, partly because it was every bit as good as the supermarket’s Châteauneuf-du-Pape, which retails at nearly twice the price. Syrah based – unusual in this part of France – with 22% Grenache and 4% Carignan – it has aromas of tapenade and mountain herbs, a palate of mulberry and blackberry and impressive texture, grip and palate weight. Perfect with a winter stew.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-30Similar Wines: £10-14, 90-94, France, Red, Carignan, Grenache, Syrah
95

2023 A Pie de Tierra Fuerza Bruta Vino de Paraje, Valle del Alberche, Sierra de Gredos

( £27.60, 13%, Parched Online, The Sourcing Table )

So pale it could almost be a rosado, this is a refined, ethereal Garnacha from vines planted on granite soils at 500 metres. Fermented with stems for texture and perfume, it’s a subtle, layered, haunting red from young winemakers Aitor Paul and David Villamiel, with aromas of ginger, Turkish Delight and forest floor, graceful, caressing tannins and a savoury finish of wild strawberry and clove.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-32Similar Wines: £30-35, 95-100, Spain, Red, Garnacha
93

2022 Carinus Family Vineyards Syrah, Polkadraai Hills, Stellenbosch

( £14.95, 13.5%, The Wine Society )

Over the last decade or so, the Polkadraai Hills in Stellenbosch have emerged as one of the best places in the world to grow Syrah. It’s a region that produces wines that can go toe-to-toe with the best of the northern Rhône. This wine from Danie Carinus’ own vines, vinified by superstar winemaker Lukas van Loggerenberg, is crazily good value for money. It has enticing clove, lavender and white pepper aromas, tangy blackberry and tapenade flavours and a whisper of oak. Delicious.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-32Similar Wines: £10-15, 90-94, South Africa, Red, Syrah
92

2024 Famille Bougrier Les Terrasses Cabernet Franc, Saint Nicolas de Bourgueil, Loire Valley

( £11.50, 12%, Tesco )

Asked to compile a list of my favourite five red grapes, I’d definitely include Cabernet Franc – and not Cabernet Sauvignon. This fresh, typically medium-bodied example from Saint Nicolas de Bourgueil is wonderfully bright and appealing,  with rocket, coriander and graphite aromas and a tangy, unwooded palate of black cherry and red pepper framed by granular tannins.

BuyDrinking window: 2025-30Similar Wines: £10-15, 90-94, France, Red, Cabernet Franc
93

2012 Weinert Cavas de Weinert, Mendoza

( £27, 14% )

Weinert is one of the most proudly traditional producers in Argentina, making wines that are squirrelled away for years in large wooden casks before release. This is a seamless blend of equal parts Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot with 20% Malbec. It’s ripe, intense and savoury with mature, autumnal aromas of leather, incense and fallen leaves and a palate that combines structure and backbone with sinewy tannins and flavours of red berries, cassis and a spicy, balsamic twist. Great value at under £30.

BuyDrinking window: 2024-30Similar Wines: 90-94, Argentina, Red, Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec, Merlot